The Pros And Cons Of Hardwood Flooring (2023)

Homebuyers have long salivated over the prospect of having hardwood floors. But are they all that they’re cracked up to be? Hardwood floors are a timeless look that works well for any kind of decorating motif. Many point to the return on investment of hardwood floors as a selling point if they’re considering adding them, and hardwood floors will pay off in resale value. If you can handle the wear and tear of hardwood floors, they’re hard to beat.

Advertisement

THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT AND NOT EDITORIAL CONTENT. Please note that we do receive compensation for any products you buy or sign up to via this advertisement, and that compensation impacts the ranking and placement of any offers listed herein. We do not present information about every offer available. The information and savings numbers depicted above are for demonstration purposes only, and your results may vary.

Compare Quotes From Top-rated Local Flooring Contractors

Free, No-commitment Estimates

What Is Hardwood Flooring?

Everyone seems to want them but what makes hardwood floors so special? Hardwood floors come in a wide variety from the type of wood used to the way the wood is cut and to how the wood gets assembled.

Typical wood selections for hardwood floors include oak, pine, maple, fir, birch, cherry, beech and even bamboo. The wood gets cut into either strips, which come as tongue-in-groove, planks, which are also tongue-in-groove or wood tile, which gets laid in geometric patterns.

Then there are wood laminates and engineered wood that mimic the look of hardwood floors. Laminate flooring has several layers on top of a base fiberboard. The top layer has a wear layer to protect the surface. Engineered wood has a real wood surface, albeit a thin layer, above a plywood substrate.

If you choose real hardwood, you can pick between pre-finished and unfinished flooring. Pre-finished flooring comes sanded and sealed, which eliminates some steps during installation.

Hardwood Floor Pros

  • Look: No other flooring option compares to the classic elegance of hardwood floors. People love older homes because they have hardwood floors and because hardwood floors connotate a coziness that carpet and others can’t touch.
  • Durability: With a little TLC, hardwood floors will last a lifetime, and then some. Most experts recommend refinishing hardwood floors every 10 years to keep them looking good. That can mean sanding and applying a new coat of finish.
  • Maintenance: Cleaning hardwood floors is a cinch, but it does mean frequent sweeping and mopping. A solution of vinegar and water will work best for cleaning.
  • Versatility: Hardwood floors provide a neutral background that allows for a multitude of decorating looks. Carpet typically has to complement the color scheme of a room, where hardwood floors don’t have that problem. Plus, hardwood floors can be stained to a color that best fits your needs.
  • Allergen reducer: Hardwood floors don’t collect dust and other allergens like carpet will and that makes it a better option for those with respiratory issues and allergies.
  • Return on investment: The National Association of Realtors reported in 2019 that homeowners can recoup 106% of their investment in hardwood floors with the average cost of installation running about $4,700.

Hardwood Floor Cons

  • Cost: Though hardwood floors provide a better than most return on investment, they still come with some upfront costs that give some homeowners pause. Hardwood floor installation can average between $6 and $12 per square foot, depending upon the type of material used. Materials typically cost between $3 and $7 per square foot and labor adds around $3 to $5 per square foot.
  • Scratches and gouges: Despite your best intentions with hardwood floors, you’re bound to see some scratches and gouges over time. The scratches and gouges are just a minor concern because you can refinish hardwood floors to eliminate those eyesores.
  • Moisture damage: Should those scratches and gouges get too deep and you spill some liquid or water seeps in through a window after a rain, you need to wipe up any moisture quickly to prevent hardwood floors from swelling or cupping.
  • Noise: Hardwood floors, especially older floors, will creak when you walk around on them. You can quiet the noise by shimming joists and the subfloor or fill gaps between the subfloor and joist with construction adhesive.
  • Tough on pets: Pets can scratch up your floor with their claws, but the floor can also cause them to slip and slide. Hardwood floors can be especially tough on older dogs, who can’t get a grip to get up off the floor.

Advertisement

THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT AND NOT EDITORIAL CONTENT. Please note that we do receive compensation for any products you buy or sign up to via this advertisement, and that compensation impacts the ranking and placement of any offers listed herein. We do not present information about every offer available. The information and savings numbers depicted above are for demonstration purposes only, and your results may vary.

Using your home's equity is an easy way to fund your new floors!

Get prequalified in minutes by clicking on your state.

Learn More

Hardwood Floor Cost

Hardwood floors typically cost between $6 and $12 per square foot, depending upon the type of wood you choose and labor costs. Hardwood floor costs can rise as high as $23 per square foot for materials and labor when you need your old floor removed and trim work. The total cost of the project averages around $4,200 with a range between $2,300 and $6,000.

Hardwood Floor Maintenance and Care

Hardwood floors might require a little more attention because dirt and dust tend to be more visible, but cleanup just means grabbing a broom and sweeping. In order to wash the floors, use a mixture of vinegar and water. You can also use a wood-cleaning product like Murphy Oil Soap.

Water with a few drops of castile soap or dish soap will work as well. Using a mop to clean a hardwood floor isn’t generally recommended because you don’t want a puddle of water on hardwood floors. A wet, microfiber mop will work best.

Hardwood Floor Design Options

Hardwood floors are usually designed in planks or strips, but some homeowners like geometric patterns. Some will use a diagonal pattern or a paquet pattern, plus there’s the similar herringbone pattern for hardwood floors. Chevron is another pattern for hardwood floors and some will choose a checkerboard pattern that looks like Jenga pieces put together.

Hardwood Floor Installation

Installing hardwood floors is a chore, especially if you plan on doing it yourself. First, you have to rip up your old floor and then decide how you’re going to install hardwood floors: nail down, glue down or tongue-in-groove.

Glue down and tongue-in-groove are easier to install because nail down requires a wooden subfloor and special tools like a floor nailer. If you choose nail-down hardwood floors, you might consider hiring the work out to save you some time and possible aggravation.

Hardwood Floor Lifespan

Hardwood floors are known to last decades if properly maintained. Hardwood floors tend to need refinishing every 10 years or so to keep their luster. Expect hardwood floors to last the life of the house.

Hardwood Floor Top Brands

Top hardwood floor brands include:

  • Bruce Hardwood Flooring: The company dates to 1884 and features hardwood and engineered hardwood floors.
  • Mohawk Industries: Mohawk is an industry leader that will have whatever kind of hardwood floor you want.
  • Shaw Floors: Shaw rivals Mohawk and has loads of hardwood floor options.
    Armstrong Flooring: Like the other big flooring brands, Armstrong has a big selection—256 hardwood options and 156 engineered wood selections.
  • Carlisle Wide Plank Floors: If you want something a little more niche, Carlisle Wide Plank Floors does a good job of that.

Hardwood Floor Bottom Line

Hardwood floors might have an upfront cost that turns people away, but it’s hard to beat for its quality and value. Many people love the look of hardwood floors and it’s proven one of the best return on investment home improvement ideas. You can save some money by removing your old floor yourself and/or installing the new hardwood floor, too. If you choose to install hardwood floors on your own, you may want to choose a type of hardwood floor you can glue or a tongue-in-groove hardwood floor style. A nail-down hardwood floor requires more work and it’s often best left to the pros to do.

Advertisement

THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT AND NOT EDITORIAL CONTENT. Please note that we do receive compensation for any products you buy or sign up to via this advertisement, and that compensation impacts the ranking and placement of any offers listed herein. We do not present information about every offer available. The information and savings numbers depicted above are for demonstration purposes only, and your results may vary.

Compare Quotes From Top-rated Local Flooring Contractors

Free, No-commitment Estimates


Your Home. Your Decisions. Our Support.

Get expert advice on your home, design tips, how much to pay for pros and hiring experts, delivered to you daily.

Thanks & Welcome to the Forbes Home Improvement Community!

{{ newsletterState.emailErrorMsg }}

I agree to receive the Forbes Home newsletter via e-mail. Please see our Privacy Policy for more information and details on how to opt out.

FAQs

The Pros And Cons Of Hardwood Flooring? ›

There's a lot to like about hardwood flooring. It brings a bit of nature's beauty into your home and it goes with just about any decor, be it traditional, contemporary, rustic or a stylish mash-up. It requires an investment of both time and money, but when the dust settles, wood floors are almost always worth it.

Are hardwood floors worth it? ›

There's a lot to like about hardwood flooring. It brings a bit of nature's beauty into your home and it goes with just about any decor, be it traditional, contemporary, rustic or a stylish mash-up. It requires an investment of both time and money, but when the dust settles, wood floors are almost always worth it.

Is wood flooring high maintenance? ›

Hardwood floors are not low maintenance by any stretch of the imagination. They require regular sweeping and cleaning to prevent surface damage and to keep them looking nice. And you need to clean them with products that won't damage the finish, and be extra careful with water.

In what room should you avoid using wood floors? ›

The Bathroom Floors

It's not secret that moisture can cause major damage to hardwood floors over time. Things like steamy showers and spills can prematurely age wood floors and creating damage. For immediate destruction to wood flooring an overflowing toilet could quickly happen spell the end for your wood floors.

Where should you not put hardwood floors? ›

You may love the look of your hardwood flooring, but it's really not a good idea to put it in your laundry room. Foyer– All manner of things can be tracked in from outside, and the foyer of your home will bear the brunt of all of them. Sand, dirt, mud, water, snow, and more can all damage hardwood.

When should you not install hardwood floors? ›

Hardwood Flooring During the Humid Seasons

During the hotter and more humid months of the year, hardwood flooring will absorb moisture from the air, which causes it to expand and swell. The expansion of the boards can cause them to warp.

Which floor is better hardwood or laminate? ›

Hardwood floors typically last much longer than laminate, though they do need occasional refinishing. It's also usually easier to repair a hardwood floor, often with some sanding and staining, whereas damaged laminate might need to be replaced altogether.

Do hardwood floors scratch easily? ›

Wood Flooring will scratch. Being a natural product there is truly no way of getting away from this fact. Scratches however need not necessarily be looked at as a bad thing with wooden flooring. Many believe that these markings very much add to the character of the flooring - taking away from the pristine nature.

What is better than hardwood floors? ›

Engineered wood flooring is a better choice in high-moisture environments than solid hardwood, making it a better option for kitchens, bathrooms and basements. But, for whole-house installations, both flooring options offer a wide range of style choices.

What kind of hardwood floor is best? ›

The best hardwood floors are made with wood species that are readily available and — you guessed it — very hard. Oak flooring, maple flooring and cherry flooring are all good choices. Other species include bamboo (which is actually a grass), walnut, ash and mahogany.

Are hardwood floors healthier than carpet? ›

Carpet vs Hardwood: The Final Verdict

According to the above, hardwood and carpet flooring are equally healthy. However, carpets are harder to clean properly, making them less ideal for people with allergies or asthma.

How often should I mop my hardwood floors? ›

Routine cleaning

In high-traffic areas, like the dining room and kitchen, sweep or vacuum daily if possible and mop hardwood floors once or twice a week. Mop less-trafficked areas once a month or once a season.

Can wooden floors be mopped everyday? ›

The best way to clean hardwood floors and keep them in shape is to stick to a regular schedule of maintenance. Sweep, dust or dry mop daily. Vacuum weekly. Clean heavy-traffic areas with a damp mop twice a month.

Do I need rugs on hardwood floors? ›

Rugs protect your floors.

Daily life, along with heavy furniture, can cause permanent damage to your hardwood floors if you're not careful. So keep your floors in good shape by adding a rug! Rugs (plus a rug pad) will eliminate any potential damage a heavy piece of furniture can do.

What destroys hardwood floors? ›

7 Things That Can Ruin Your Hardwood Floors
  • Too Much Sunlight. ...
  • Using The Wrong Area Rugs. ...
  • Vacuuming With The Brush On. ...
  • High Heels & Pet Nails. ...
  • Using The Wrong Cleaning Tools. ...
  • Sliding Furniture Around. ...
  • Not Getting Professional Help.
Jul 18, 2019

Do hardwood floors attract bugs? ›

Despite being the best choice for underneath floor heating, hardwood flooring is not exceptional when it comes to hardwood pest infestation. Some wood pest such as termites, powder post beetle, carpenters ants, and some bugs may cause irreparable damage to your wood floors, making them spotty and aged.

What time of year is best to install wood floors? ›

Moisture in Spring and Summer

Fall is a perfect season for hardwood flooring installation because the cool, crisp weather exposes your hardwood flooring to less moisture.

How long do hardwood floors last? ›

On average, a hardwood flooring finish lasts approximately ten years. But with proper care and maintenance, it can last much longer.

When did they stop putting hardwood floors in homes? ›

In fact the early mid mod period (late 40's – early 50's) is about the last time that hardwood floors were common in builder grade houses.

Is it OK to have hardwood floors in a kitchen? ›

If you're looking for a gorgeous, durable flooring option for your kitchen, wood floors may be the answer. It's been popular for centuries, and its timeless design never goes out of style. Plus, "we see this trend a lot because people love the feel of wood underfoot.

How often should wood floors be replaced? ›

In the same respect, most properly maintained hardwood floors can go anywhere from 20 to 30 years without needing any significant work done. Their longevity makes hardwood floors a great investment for any house. However, there will come a time when every hardwood floor will need to either be refinished or replaced.

Which direction should hardwood floors be laid? ›

The most common way to lay hardwood flooring is by aligning the planks parallel to the longest wall. Apart from a few exceptions like sagging joists, this is the preferred direction to lay wood floors because it aesthetically provides the best result.

Should I get hardwood or vinyl flooring? ›

Vinyl flooring is waterproof, so it's usable in any area of the home, including bathrooms and low-grade basements where water or moisture is a concern. Yet, hardwood floors can be damaged, warped, or even grow mold when exposed to water or moisture because they soak up liquids easily.

What type of wood flooring lasts the longest? ›

Teak: Teak has much to offer when it comes to real wood flooring. Its 2330 Janka rating makes it one of the hardest woods available, but its high-gloss finish, natural oils and resins, and high water resistance make it ideal for almost any room in your home or business.

What type of flooring holds up the best? ›

Tile is the highest-rated flooring among the categories we test,” says Enrique de Paz, who leads flooring testing at Consumer Reports. “It doesn't wear out, scratch, or stain. Its color doesn't fade, it's waterproof, and it is surprisingly slip-resistant, even when wet.

Does sweeping scratch hardwood floors? ›

Sweeping. Dirt, dust, and other abrasive particles can gather and scratch the floor without you even noticing. If you don't sweep on a regular basis, it can slowly damage your hardwood floors. If you want to ruin your floors, don't sweep them.

Do dogs nails damage hardwood floors? ›

Nails scratch a typical hardwood finish.

Over just a few months, your wood floor will begin to look dull and worn just because of all the scratches on the finish from dog nails. Unlike cats, dogs do not fully retract their nails, so they are always clicking on the floor when they walk.

Do hardwood floors make your house dusty? ›

The problem with sweeping wood floors is that it just kicks dust into the air. That dust will eventually settle right back down, meaning you're really just spreading dirt and allergens around.

What is the next best thing to hardwood? ›

5 Alternatives to Traditional Hardwood Floors
  • Cork Flooring. An increasingly popular choice for home renovations is cork flooring, a completely renewable alternative that is available in both tiles and planks. ...
  • Vinyl or Laminate. ...
  • Ceramic Tile Floors. ...
  • Bamboo Floors. ...
  • Carpet Tiles.

Why do people prefer hardwood flooring? ›

Hardwood flooring is tough and durable, especially certain species. Most homeowners only purchase wood flooring once for their home because hardwood flooring is so durable. Many home's wood floors last so long because they can be refinished, unlike carpet or laminate.

Is light or dark wood floors better? ›

Darker floors are better suited for larger rooms and open floor plans. Another seemingly unrelated factor to consider is how often you clean your floors. Light hardwood flooring can hide small flaws, dirt, and debris, but anything larger will be very noticeable.

What is the most popular wood flooring right now? ›

Oak floors continue their dominance.

Oak, bamboo, and maple continue to be the most popular hardwood options, with walnut and its striking grain making an occasional appearance.

What color wood floor is timeless? ›

Neutral shades such as light brown, gray, and black are timeless classics that will look good for years to come. These hues make a great backdrop for any room in your home, so you can easily accessorize the space without worrying about the color clashing with your floors.

What is the most popular color of hardwood floors? ›

Brown Hardwood Flooring

Best known as the traditional color of hardwood flooring, shades of brown are still as popular as ever. Much like tan-toned hardwood, brown flooring is suited for any aesthetic. Lighter tones can set the basis of a neutral design, while deeper tones have the power to convey depth and luxury.

Does replacing carpet with hardwood increase value? ›

There's no consensus on an exact percentage, but many experts have said it's between 3% and 5%. So replacing carpet with hardwood flooring can definitely make a difference in your selling price. In fact, one study found that 54% of home buyers said they'd be willing to pay more—up to $2,080—for hardwood floors.

Why do people prefer carpet over hardwood? ›

At the end of the day, the decision between carpet or hardwood floors is primarily based on preference. Many people prefer carpet in bedrooms because they enjoy a softer surface. And in the case of two or three-story homes, carpet can also help reduce noise.

Is it cheaper to install carpet or hardwood floors? ›

When comparing the cost of installing hardwood floors versus carpet, quality hardwood flooring will almost always be a larger investment. Installing hardwood floors on average costs between $12 and $20 per square foot, while carpet costs about $6 to $12 per square foot.

Is hardwood really better than laminate? ›

Hardwood floors can last much longer than laminate, which is typically limited to a lifespan of between 15 and 25 years. That said, hardwood flooring will usually show wear and tear more much quickly than laminate due to its susceptibility to scratches, dents, and discolorations.

How many years do wood floors last? ›

Besides, a properly maintained wood floor can go 20 or 30 years or more before needing to be refinished, says Lupresto. And it can be sanded and refinished "easily six or seven times" over its lifetime, he says.

What type of wood flooring is best? ›

The best hardwood floors are made with wood species that are readily available and — you guessed it — very hard. Oak flooring, maple flooring and cherry flooring are all good choices. Other species include bamboo (which is actually a grass), walnut, ash and mahogany.

What is the downside to laminate flooring? ›

While laminate flooring has many strong points, its most significant downside is its poor resistence to water. Laminate flooring can tolerate some water on top surface but it should not be allowed to pool and remain for long. Otherwise, the water may seep below and affect the sensitive core layer.

Does hardwood scratch easier than laminate? ›

Hardwood floors can be scratched easier than laminate floors; however scratches are much easier to fix with real hardwood flooring.

Why is wood flooring not recommended? ›

Not Resistant to Humidty: Wood can be damaged by spills, standing liquids, and humidity which is why wood floors are not recommend for areas of high moisture and humidity such as full bathrooms.

How often should hardwood floors be redone? ›

How often can I refinish my floors? Depending on a floor's thickness and the experience of the flooring professional, a floor can be sanded around 4-6 times in its entire life. Hardwood floors can be refinished every 7-10 years, making the 4-6 refinishes more than enough.

What time of year is best to install hardwood floors? ›

Moisture in Spring and Summer

Fall is a perfect season for hardwood flooring installation because the cool, crisp weather exposes your hardwood flooring to less moisture.

What year did they stop putting hardwood floors in houses? ›

In fact the early mid mod period (late 40's – early 50's) is about the last time that hardwood floors were common in builder grade houses.

Do hardwood floors increase home value? ›

While there are many factors that influence a home's value, hardwood flooring can certainly increase its worth. Not only does it add a warm and inviting aesthetic to any living space, but it also makes a home easier to sell and can even add resale value when the time comes.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated: 13/01/2024

Views: 6283

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.